Why Does Noise Make Bread Fall?

Table of Contents Hide
  1. Overproofing
  2. Water
  3. Liquids

You may have heard that noise makes bread fall, but what exactly causes this? If you have not baked bread before, you’ve probably wondered how much noise makes bread fall, and if it’s related to the overproofing process. Here are some reasons why noise does cause bread to fall. Read on to learn more! During the proofing process, yeast takes up all of the sugars in the dough. It can then no longer produce carbon dioxide.

OnlySilent featured on media
Disclosure : Some of the links below are affiliate links, meaning at no additional cost, I will earn a commission if you click through and make a purchase. As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases.


When making bread, overproofing is a very common mistake. This practice leads to an untidy loaf, so be sure to follow the instructions on the bread recipe exactly. A simple poke test is one way to check if the bread is proofed properly. When the dough is just right, the indentation will slowly rise back up. If the indentation does not come back up, you are overproofing.

Overproofing your dough will cause your bread to flatten and fall because the gluten mesh in the dough has not developed enough carbon dioxide to hold its volume. This is a major cause of flattening bread. A better method is to proof the dough for approximately two hours and then bake the bread. However, this is not always possible. You can also let your dough rest for a few minutes before attempting the bread proofing process.

Overproofing your dough is a common baking mistake that will cause your bread to fall when baked. This is because the yeast has been exhausted and cannot continue to expand once it has been baked. In addition, if you leave it in the proofing area for too long, the dough will collapse in the oven. Therefore, it is crucial to check the bread’s proofing time to avoid making the bread fall. A properly proofed dough is able to retain its shape well after it has risen.

The opposite of overproofing is under-proofing. It results in a dough that collapses after its gasses expand and create an overly dense centre. There are various ways to prevent overproofing, including using special proofing equipment. Using an electric kettle can create an ideal environment for the dough, allowing it to rest longer and develop a more tender texture. A traditional bread proofing device is a banneton.

The temperature of the oven can also contribute to the collapse of the loaf. Even if the dough is proving properly in a warm environment, the temperature may be too low to bake it in a conventional oven. Another cause of overproofing is too much liquid or too little flour. The dough might be too wet. If this is the case, you can add more flour to get the consistency you desire. If you want your bread to rise without falling apart, try kneading the dough before proofing.


The key to making delicious, moist bread is a balanced ratio of water and flour. Too much water or too little water results in a sticky, unyielding dough. A good compromise is a blend of medium and hard water. Most potable water is suitable for baking bread. The exact amount of water needed depends on the recipe. Water should be between 50-57 percent. It should be soft enough to make dough pliable, but not so wet that it makes the dough fall apart or be ultra-sticky.

The type of water you use can also make a difference in the final outcome of the bread. The best water to use for baking bread is one that is medium in hardness, with about 100 to 150 parts per million of minerals. However, if you cannot find water of this hardness, you can still use tap water. The water should have enough minerals for the yeast to feed on, but not too few. If you use demineralized water, it will be devoid of the necessary minerals for baking.


In baking, liquid ingredients such as milk, fruit juices, vegetable broth, and potato water are used to produce a dough or batter. These ingredients hydrate the flour, allowing it to develop gluten and starch, forming the basic structure of a baked product. They also dissolve sugar and salt, as well as contribute moisture and enhance the mouthfeel of baked goods. The addition of liquids to bread dough makes the final product moister and more flavorful.

The liquids in bread machines include water, milk, buttermilk, yogurt, sour cream, soft cheeses, and fruit. Butter and eggs are also liquids, but they are on the borderline between liquid and solid. Too much butter or egg will collapse the loaf. Liquids are also necessary to activate yeast in the dough, which will help the loaf rise. Too little liquid will result in a dense loaf, while too much will collapse it.

Another cause of falling bread is too much water and yeast. If the dough is too wet, reduce the water or remove an egg. Fresh yeast is also a culprit, as it may be too weak or old. You should use 2 to 2 1/2 teaspoons of fresh yeast for baking. However, if the liquids are too hot, you might end up with a bread that falls. So, be sure to reduce the amount of water before kneading.